This is the “sound” of a great chamber music rehearsal.
Whereas many consider classical music to be a “fixed” thing, more or less set in stone way back when (or perhaps yesterday) by the composer, I find it much more fun—and much closer to the “compositional mindset”—to allow the novel idea, the heretofore unthought-of thought, the naughty switcheroo, the radical rewrite…well, an IDEA! to enter the arena and offer itself as a possibility. Perhaps we end up tossing it out, but the process of considering options is liberating in itself.
My dear AC is the ringmaster of this particularly delightful and surprisingly practical circus. If more than ten minutes of rehearsal go by without AC uttering “Wait! I Have an Idea!” then I fear something is amiss.
While—I confess—I frequently have the knee-jerk reaction that you SIMPLY CAN’T DO THAT (call it "Orchestra-On-The-Brain” syndrome), it often turns out that the idea, or another that follows on its heels, is pure genius!
Recently such a sequence occurred. My knee jerked and I said: “NO!” to AC, “your idea veers TOO FAR from the score” (after all, this was recent music…), alters the soundscape TOO MUCH—in short, is NON-PERMESSO.
But God—the God of Good Ideas and Permission—smote me down! For immediately thereupon, what did I myself utter but “Wait!… I Have an Idea!”. And my idea was waaaaay more radical than AC’s, which I had voted to scrub a mere 30 seconds earlier. Apparently, the God of Good Ideas and Permission has a sense of humor…
And AC, being not afflicted with the dreaded OOTB syndrome, was happy to indulge me my way-radical idea, and, after several other volleys of “I Have an Idea!” ping-pong, we arrived at an extra-genius version of music that was already damn good! (Someday we may even play our version for the composer!)
Now, if only we had written down exactly what we cooked up…